JAMAICA | Opposition Blasts 'Second-Tier' Honor Proposal for Marley, Miss Lou

KINGSTON, Jamaica - In a scathing rebuke, Opposition Spokesperson Dr. Deborah Hickling Gordon has condemned the government's proposal to create a new "second-tier" national honor for cultural icons Bob Marley and Louise "Miss Lou" Bennett Coverley, calling it a diminishment of their legacy and "another retrograde proposal" affecting Jamaica's African heritage.

The government's planned introduction of an "Order of National Icon" category has sparked controversy, particularly as it's designed for luminaries whose contributions allegedly "fall short of" National Hero criteria. This revelation comes amid Jamaica's heritage celebrations, adding fuel to an already heated cultural debate.

"Their heroism took a different form at a different time on Jamaica's decolonisation journey," declared Hickling Gordon, emphasizing that both Marley and Miss Lou championed "mental and social liberation during highly charged, transformative political times."

The Opposition Spokesperson didn't mince words in her criticism of the government's approach. "The suggestion that Miss Lou and Bob Marley's work is somehow 'less than' that of our existing National Heroes is further evidence of the government's scant regard for Jamaican culture and its expressions," she asserted.

Drawing on Miss Lou's own vernacular, Hickling Gordon argued that the proposed second-tier status "'less-counts' the struggle, sacrifice, experiences, and cultural expressions that have helped thousands of Jamaicans embrace their identity, create wealth, and feel like 'smaddy' (somebody)."

Rather than legislative changes, the Opposition advocates for public consultation and enhanced education about heroism criteria, following recommendations from Professor Nettleford's initial report. "Thirty years after the first report and seventeen years after the second, global trends emphasize the importance of integrating culture, creativity, and expression in nation-building growth strategies," Hickling Gordon noted.

The People's National Party (PNP) has pledged to elevate both cultural icons to full National Hero status following the next general election, building on Opposition Leader Mark Golding's March 2024 commitment regarding Marley. The party plans to utilize existing legislation's provisions for an Advisory Committee to engage in public consultations on the matter.

This debate over national recognition highlights an ongoing tension in Jamaica's cultural landscape, as the nation grapples with how best to honor its most influential cultural figures.

-30-