BAHAMAS | Death in Paradise: American Family Fights for Truth in Bahamas Tragedy

NASSAU, Bahamas,  April 12, 2025 — Within mere hours of checking into what should have been an idyllic family getaway, 23-year-old Dinari McAlmont's vacation turned fatal under circumstances his family calls suspicious and violent.

His body, discovered lifeless on the shores of Paradise Island just 12 hours after his arrival in the Bahamas, has unleashed a torrent of questions that local authorities seem determined to dismiss, and his family refuses to let die.

"When I looked at the photo they showed me, my son was beaten; he was traumatized," declares Michelle McAlmont, her voice quivering with grief and rage. "They beat my son down in the sand. I need justice for my baby. I need justice." The official cause of death — "drowning" — feels to the family like a convenient conclusion, hastily rubber-stamped to avoid deeper scrutiny into what they believe was a brutal attack.

The McAlmonts, Guyanese Americans from Maryland, arrived at the Atlantis Paradise Bahamas resort on April 4 for what should have been a joyful vacation. Instead, they've found themselves thrust into an international battle for truth in a paradise turned purgatory.

The timeline is as disturbing as it is brief: after dinner that evening, Dinari mentioned feeling cold and went to retrieve a jacket just before 9 p.m. When he failed to return, his increasingly anxious parents reported him missing around 11 p.m. and began a frantic search. Officials discovered his body on the shoreline at 5:30 a.m. the next morning.

At the center of their fight is an autopsy report they believe conceals more than it reveals. "The autopsy was not comprehensive enough," Michelle insists. "We want to know what factors led to the drowning. What other evidence made them believe that? My son had foaming at the mouth — something else happened.

Was he choked and pushed under the water? Was he held under, then gagged, causing his death?" Her suspicions are bolstered by what she describes as clear evidence of violence on her son's body. "There is foul play," she told Fox 5 DC. "Because of all the bruises and you can see when somebody is abused and hit at, yes, and that is what I am saying."

Her questions echo the account of a hotel guest who reported hearing blood-curdling screams from the beach in the pre-dawn hours of April 5th. "At first I thought it was seagulls," the witness recounted, "but then I distinctly heard someone screaming 'Help!' and a child yelling 'Mommy!'"

These chilling details stand in stark contrast to the official determination by the Royal Bahamas Police Force, who stated in a Wednesday news conference: "A post-mortem examination was performed, and the pathologist's findings revealed that the deceased died as a result of drowning." Authorities have insisted they don't suspect foul play.

Adding insult to unimaginable injury, Bahamian officials have denied Michelle the most basic right of a grieving mother — to see her son's body in person. Instead, she was briefly shown a photograph that she says clearly displayed evidence of violence.

According to Dinari's aunt, Marcelle Bacchus, Michelle "only looked at the picture briefly and wasn't given a copy." The family was then informed that McAlmont's body would not be released to the funeral parlor on Thursday as planned due to a clerical error — his name had been misspelled on morgue paperwork and documentation had to be redone.

As the clock ticks, the McAlmont family's cry for justice has reverberated beyond the island's shores, catching the ear of American political leaders. Prince George's County Council Member Ingrid Watson called Dinari's death "a shocking and heartbreaking loss that warrants serious attention," while Senator Marco Rubio raised the stakes with a direct challenge to Bahamian authorities.

"Every American citizen deserves answers," Rubio stated. "The Bahamian authorities owe it to this family to conduct a full, impartial, and swift investigation. We will not tolerate injustice or obstruction."

The specter of evidence disappearing hangs heavy over the case. Dinari's aunt, Marcelle Bacchus, voiced what many now suspect: "This is foul play. I feel the authorities are covering up. We are terrified that evidence is disappearing right before our eyes."

In a bold move to force accountability, the family called a press conference for FridayApril 11, at at the Jones Communications Centre in Nassau. There, in the glare of international media, they demanded what has so far been denied them — the unvarnished truth about what happened to Dinari McAlmont on a beach where paradise and tragedy collided.

For now, a grieving family waits. The world watches. And somewhere in the bureaucratic maze of the Bahamas, the truth about a young man's final moments remains buried — but perhaps not for much longer.

-30-