JAMAICA | The Sweet Decline: Jamaica's Once-Mighty Sugar Industry Faces Existential Crisis

KINGSTON, Jamaica, January 12, 2025 - Jamaica's sugar industry, once the cornerstone of colonial wealth and a dark symbol of slavery, now teeters on the brink of irrelevance. From commanding over 35 sugar factories at the dawn of the millennium to a mere two operational facilities today, the industry's decline mirrors a broader tale of agricultural mismanagement and missed opportunities in the Caribbean nation.

The industry's roots run deep in Jamaica's soil and troubled history. From 1655 to 1838, sugar cane plantations served as the brutal cradle of slavery under British colonial rule, which had wrestled control from the Spanish after their 163-year reign that decimated the indigenous Arawak (Taino) people.

The British colonial masters, fixated on export agriculture, transformed the island into a profitable outpost shipping sugar, coffee, cocoa, pimento, banana, and citrus to their motherland.

Post-emancipation and independence, sugar remained the crown jewel of Jamaica's agricultural exports. The 1960s marked the industry's zenith, with sugar production soaring to 1,062 thousand tons, alongside impressive yields in cocoa (2,900 thousand tons) and the prized Blue Mountain coffee (550 thousand boxes).

However, post-independence governments have treated the sugar cane industry with what many consider negligent disdain.

Prime agricultural lands once dedicated to sugar production have been systematically diverted to housing and other non-agricultural purposes, a policy that critics argue requires drastic reversal to salvage what remains of this once-thriving sector.

Recent attempts to breathe life into the ailing industry have met with skepticism. The Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Mining's New Year announcement of a Sugar Industry Authority Training Institute (SIATI) - separate from the existing Sugar Industry Research Institute (SIRI) - has been met with muted enthusiasm.

While any new initiative might seem refreshing for the beleaguered industry, critics argue that SIATI risks becoming a 'white elephant' without concurrent efforts to establish sufficient sugar cane acreage on suitable lands, with strategic access to factories and clear paths to sustainability and profitability.

The institutional landscape surrounding sugar production has become a labyrinth of bureaucracy. A cacophony of organizations - the Sugar Manufacturing Corporation (SMC), All Island Jamaica Cane Farmers Association (AIJCFA), Sugar Producers' Federation (SPF), and the more recently added Sugar Company of Jamaica Holding Company (SCJH) - operate in apparent disharmony, further complicating revival efforts.

Adding to these concerns, the Chinese-managed Pan Caribbean Company, which controls some of Jamaica's prime sugar cane lands through its ownership of the Frome facility, is significantly underperforming. Industry insiders whisper fears that these valuable lands might be repurposed into a Western Logistics Hub, dealing another blow to sugar production.

A glimmer of hope emerged recently when Tropical Sugar Company Limited (TSCL) expressed interest in reviving sugar production through innovative integration of renewable energy. Such initiatives could prove crucial for communities like South Clarendon, where the reopening of Monymusk factory could spark economic revival and potentially help curb crime through increased employment opportunities.

The stark reality of Jamaica's current sugar production paints a troubling picture. Only two privately owned factories remain operational: Frome in Westmoreland and Worthy Park in St Catherine.

Both facilities process cane from various sources, including the historic Appleton Estate in St Elizabeth. Yet their combined 2023 output of 35,000 tons falls drastically short of the national demand of 150,000 tons, forcing Jamaica to import over 100,000 tons annually to satisfy local consumption.

Perhaps most jarring is the state of Jamaica's renowned rum industry. In what many consider a national embarrassment, the country now imports all its molasses for rum production - a situation costing the fragile economy US$27 million in foreign exchange for molasses alone in 2022, with an additional US$118 million spent on sugar and related products.

The irony isn't lost on industry veterans who remember when the 'Spirit Pool' - the rum production arm of the sugar industry - operated entirely on domestic molasses.

However, hope isn't entirely lost. Experts suggest that planting an additional 150,000 acres of sugar cane could reverse these trends within five years, potentially allowing for the reopening of facilities like Monymusk.

The sugar industry presents a unique opportunity for agricultural revival, thanks to its existing infrastructure of large fields and factories, strong domestic market, and the ability to house workers, including potential labor from neighboring countries.

As Jamaica stands at this crossroads, the decision to revitalize its sugar industry isn't merely about preserving a historical legacy - it's about reclaiming economic independence and agricultural self-sufficiency.

The question remains: will policymakers finally give this once-mighty industry the attention it deserves, or will they continue to watch as this sweet heritage slowly dissolves?

-30-