JAMAICA | The Victory That Whispers: Jamaica's 2025 Electoral Enigma

KINGSTON, Jamaica, September 7, 2025 - Victory celebrations are supposed to roar. They're meant to paint the streets green with jubilant motorcades, fill the air with horns and dancehall, and see the symbolic green bushes sweeping away the orange remnants of the opposition.

But on September 4, 2025, when Andrew Holness's Jamaica Labour Party clinched its historic third consecutive term, Jamaica witnessed something unprecedented: a victory that whispered.

The silence was deafening. No widespread dancing in Half Way Tree. No triumphant convoys snaking through Kingston. Just an uneasy quiet that settled over the island like morning mist over the Blue Mountains. According to those "wicked, malicious people" on social media, the JLP had decided they were not going to lose this election—even if they had to "buy it or colt the game."

When Numbers Tell Stories

The official results showed the JLP securing 35 of 63 parliamentary seats to the PNP's 28 Jamaican PM Holness wins third term in fractious election | Politics News | Al Jazeera

a victory, certainly, but one that raises more questions than it answers. Consider the arithmetic of democracy: the JLP received 413,814 votes to the PNP's 403,340, a mere 10,474-vote difference in a nation of 2.8 million. This wasn't a mandate; it was a mathematical technicality.

But the real story emerged in the counting rooms, particularly in St. Andrew West Central, where Prime Minister Holness defended his seat. Technical "glitches" with the Electronic Voter Identification System (EVIS) plagued traditionally PNP-supporting areas like Balcombe Drive Primary, where frustrated voters left without casting ballots Jamaica Election 2025 Results - Provided by Jamaica Elections

The whispers became deafening when Holness's vote count mysteriously catapulted during counting, with no rational explanation for the massive gaps in PNP stronghold numbers.

Social media erupted. The technical challenges that conveniently affected opposition areas weren't just suspicious—they were brazenly obvious. Yet from the halls of Jamaica House came only silence. No explanation. No transparency. No accountability.

The Pyrrhic Nature of Power

History will record Holness as the first JLP leader to win three consecutive terms, joining P.J. Patterson in that exclusive club. But what kind of victory is this? In 2020, the JLP demolished the PNP 49-14. Today, they scraped by with 35-28, hemorrhaging 15 seats in what can only be described as a rejection disguised as a win.

With only 39.5% voter turnout—barely higher than 2020's pandemic-affected 37% more than three in five eligible Jamaicans chose silence over participation. This wasn't voter apathy; it was voter apostasy—a mass exodus from faith in the democratic process itself.

Mark Golding's PNP gained an extraordinary 97,000 votes over 2020, flipping 15 constituencies. Golding himself crushed his opponent in Southern St. Andrew with 9,371 votes to 1,183—an 88% victory margin that dwarfs Holness's contested win.

The PNP swept two entire parishes, Hanover and Westmoreland, while becoming the first party to capture 15 seats from an incumbent yet still lose—a statistical anomaly that defies political gravity.

The Central Kingston Debacle

Regarding the Central Kingston final count: There was a dramatic turnaround in Jamaica's 2025 general election results for this constituency.

Preliminary Results (September 3): Steve McGregor (PNP) appeared to win with 4,739 votes, while Donovan Williams (JLP) secured General Elections: PNP’s Steve McGregor wins in Kingston Central - Jamaica Observer 4,727 votes - a razor-thin 12-vote margin.

Final Count Results (September 5): However, following the final count, Donovan Williams of the JLP was declared the victor, overturning the preliminary results Official result hands Kingston Central back to JLP | Lead Stories | Jamaica Gleaner. 

Williams appeared from the counting centre with what he said was a certified copy of the results, confirming he and not McGregor had won the fiercely contested seat. (Official result hands Kingston Central back to JLP | Lead Stories | Jamaica Gleaner.) But there are major questions to be answered in relation to the official count in the Central Kingston constituency. 

The PNP’s candidate Steve McGregor in a voice note to Comrades, said he was advised that “some votes that were given to an independent candidate should have gone to the JLP from the  night of the count.I don’t know how the EOJ could have made such a mistake.”

Where did the additional votes mysteriously come from? Why were they not included in the preliminary count? How did those ballots suddenly appear as part of the final count, and why were they accepted? 

Impact: With Williams winning after the official result for Kingston Central, the JLP now holds 35 seats to the PNP's 28. (Official result hands Kingston Central back to JLP | Lead Stories | Jamaica Gleaner.)

What's Next: Based on the procedures governing elections, if McGregor is dissatisfied with the results of the official count, he could seek redress via a magisterial recount. (Official result hands Kingston Central back to JLP | Lead Stories | Jamaica Gleaner.)

This was one of the most closely watched constituencies due to the extremely narrow margin, and the JLP had indicated they would be "looking at those counts very closely" (Portland Eastern, Kingston Central among seats that JLP will be ‘looking at closely' in official count - Jamaica Observer) during the official count process.

The turnaround demonstrates how preliminary election results can sometimes be overturned during the official counting process, especially in very close races.

The Integrity Deficit

Holness entered this race under an Integrity Commission investigation for alleged illicit enrichment related to his 2021 income filings September 3 2025 Elections Preliminary Results - Electoral Commission of Jamaica.

While the probe proved inconclusive, the cloud remains. The man who promised to lead Jamaica to prosperity couldn't clearly explain his own.

The election trivia tells its own damning story: Phillip Paulwell becomes a "seven-star General," the winningest MP in East Kingston history. Wavel Hinds makes history as the first West Indies Test cricketer elected to Parliament. Peter Bunting becomes the first to represent three different constituencies. These aren't just statistics—they're evidence of a democracy in flux, where individual achievements overshadow collective dysfunction.

The Democracy That Wasn't

What does it mean when Norman Scott, the only PNP officer not to win, still pulled thousands of votes? When the PNP caucus will seat eight women to the JLP's fewer? When Dwayne Vaz secured the highest PNP vote count despite the loss? These paradoxes reveal a fractured mandate, a nation speaking in contradictions.

Holness told supporters, "Make no mistake about it, this was not an easy victory" General Elections: Holness retains St Andrew West Central seat - Jamaica Observer

—perhaps the only honest statement of the night. But uneasy victories built on technical glitches, suppressed votes, and historical low turnouts aren't victories at all. They're hostile takeovers of democracy, wrapped in constitutional legitimacy.

The Reckoning Ahead

Jamaica stands at a crossroads. The JLP may occupy Jamaica House, but they don't occupy the nation's confidence. When less than 40% of citizens bother to vote, when technical failures conveniently favor incumbents, when former prime ministers can declare "dastardly acts of political persecution" without response, democracy hasn't won—it has been hollowed out from within.

The green bushes didn't sweep because there was nothing to celebrate. Andrew Holness has his third term, but Jamaica has lost something far more precious: faith in the very system meant to give them voice. And in that silence, louder than any victory parade, lies the true verdict of September 3, 2025.

-30-